'I shall be happy to give you an opinion upon the subject in the course of a day or two. To-day is Saturday, and I hope that by Monday we may come to a conclusion.'--Sherlock Holmes to Jabez Wilson
'It's no use, John Clay,' said Holmes blandly; 'you have no chance at all.'-- Sherlock Holmes to John Clay
The two quotes above from "The Red-Headed League" are on my mind tonight. Actually, they have been on my mind since Saturday. On Saturday, I attempted to write an annotation for an upcoming project led by the lovely Madeline QuiƱones. She asked me several weeks ago to send a fairly brief note about John Clay; she knows John Clay is one of my favorite Canon characters. I agreed immediately. Why, I can write pages about John Clay, I thought at the moment. I gave Madeline an idea of where I would focus my writing and I promised to have it to her soon.
The problem is: I can write pages about John Clay. Writing 200-300 words about John Clay is proving difficult. On Saturday, I hoped to give an opinion upon the subject in the course of a day or two. I planned to bring the thing to a conclusion by Monday. Well, here it is 9:30pm or so on Monday night and I've not written a brief annotation about John Clay. Sherlock Holmes may solve his puzzles in such a timely manner. I am not as good at it. I think. I overthink. I write. I rewrite. I delete. I start over. Maddening, all round. Only 200-300 words should be child's play.
I know I'll eventually sort out how to scrunch up what I want to say about John Clay into the proper form. And hopefully say it in a thoughtful and interesting manner. The words always come eventually.
In the several years I've spent writing things about Sherlock Holmes, I've only failed to finish one of them. Generally when I start a piece, I carry it through to the (sometimes bitter) end. While I try to think about scrunching John Clay, maybe you would like to read the brief paragraphs of the only Sherlock Holmes story I ever started and then abandoned. The odd thing about the story (started in December 2020) is that it begins with words about John Clay. Of course it does.
by Margie Deck
Sherlock Holmes pulled his long cherry wood pipe from the rack, lit it with a tong, and turned to me with a smirk on his long thin face. I braced myself for what he might say, as neither that pipe nor the smirk ever preceded an evening of pleasant conversation. “Watson, I have said it before,” he began, “and I will say it again. My career has degenerated. I may well be at a crisis point. Each day I am challenged less and less. And now, I am subjected to those who find it amusing to bombard me with farfetched and false cries for help.” He tossed a telegram in my direction.
I retrieved the paper from its landing point on the chair and moved over to the light to read it. I read it, and then read it again. I now understood his disputatious mood. “Holmes,” I said, “surely this is a prank from a friend?”
“As you know well, I have no close associations except for yourself. Certainly no one who might think I would tolerate a prank,” he said with some asperity. I could not disagree with him nor actually could I imagine anyone in our ranks brave enough to attempt to trick Sherlock Holmes.
“The recent press related to that red-headed business has brought out the local lunatics, Holmes. Your success in capturing the villain John Clay has others clamoring for your attention in any way possible. It is the only explanation. Should I throw this away?”
Suddenly he put the pipe down and leaned forward in his chair. “No, wait. Read it to me.”
I held it to the light again and read it aloud to him. It ran in this way:
Dear Mr. Holmes—
I hope you will forgive this intrusion. I need your assistance in finding the real name of a man, more than likely long dead, for whom I only know a pseudonym. I also need to find his employee, who may also be dead, and the employee’s youngest son—I do not know their real names either. I realize I sound foolish, but my mother’s recent death has left me with more questions than answers and I do not know where else to turn. I will call upon you at ten in the morning on Friday next if it does not inconvenience you.
My name is John Edward Mudie although it may mean little to you. You might know me better if I tell you that I am one of the children of “Belle” (actually, Cara Mudie, Mrs. Stephen Paul Mudie, of Upper King Street, Bloomsbury) described so cleverly by Mr. Charles Dickens as a “brigand” in his small volume A Christmas Carol.
I need your help to identify the real “Mr. Scrooge”,“Bob Cratchit” and “tiny Tim Cratchit.”
—--JEM
Well, JEM, maybe someday I'll get back to you and your story. At the moment, all I can say is: It's no use...you have no chance at all.